AGENTIC-SYSTEMSMay 16, 20261 min read12 views

Model-Adaptive Tool Necessity Reveals the Knowing-Doing Gap in LLM Tool Use

A new study introduces model-adaptive tool necessity and reveals a significant 'knowing-doing gap' in LLMs, where models often recognize the need for external tools but fail to execute the corresponding actions.

Computer Science > Artificial Intelligence

Title:Model-Adaptive Tool Necessity Reveals the Knowing-Doing Gap in LLM Tool Use

Large language models (LLMs) increasingly act as autonomous agents that must decide when to answer directly vs. when to invoke external tools. Prior work studying adaptive tool use has largely treated tool necessity as a model-agnostic property, annotated by human or LLM judge, and mostly cover cases where the answer is obvious (e.g., fetching the weather vs. paraphrasing text). However, tool necessity in the wild is more nuanced due to the divergence of capability boundaries across models: a problem solvable by a strong model on its own may still require tools for a weaker one. In this work, we introduce a model-adaptive definition of tool-necessity, grounded in each model's empirical performance. Following this definition, we compare the necessity against observed tool-call behavior across four models on arithmetic and factual QA dataset, and find substantial mismatches of 26.5-54.0% and 30.8-41.8%, respectively. To diagnose the failure, we decompose tool use into two stages: an internal cognition stage that reflects whether a model believes a tool is necessary, and an execution stage that determines whether the model actually makes a tool-call action. By probing the LLM hidden states, we find that both signals are often linearly decodable, yet their probe directions become nearly orthogonal in the late-layer, last-token regime that drives the next-token action. By tracing the trajectory of samples in the two-stage process, we further discover that the majority of mismatch is concentrated in the cognition-to-action transition, not in cognition itself. These results reveal a knowing-doing gap in LLM tool-use: improving tool-use reliability requires not only better recognition of when tools are needed, but also better translation of that recognition into action.

Source: arXiv cs.AI Recent

More in this category

agentic-systems

MUX: Continuous Reasoning via Multiplexed Tokens

Researchers introduced MUX, a novel latent reasoning method that compresses discrete text-based reasoning steps into continuous multiplexed tokens. By enabling lossless superposition, MUX significantly boosts LLM reasoning efficiency and speed across complex problem-solving tasks.

agentic-systems

ProbSPARQL: Querying Knowledge Graphs with Multi-dimensional, Uncertain Numeric Data

Researchers have introduced ProbSPARQL, an upward-compatible SPARQL extension designed to query multi-dimensional and uncertain numeric measurement data within Knowledge Graphs, providing significant query performance gains for complex industrial applications.

agentic-systems

Position: AI/ML Deepfake Research is Misaligned with AI-Generated Non-Consensual Intimate Imagery (AIG-NCII)

Current AI/ML research on deepfakes focuses primarily on epistemic harms like fake news and scams, leaving a dangerous gap in addressing AI-generated non-consensual intimate imagery (AIG-NCII) and its dignity harms to victims.

NOW LET US Related – Cross-Dialect Generalization Without Retraining: Benchmarks and Evaluation of Schema-Derived Constrained Decoding for MLIR

agentic-systems

Cross-Dialect Generalization Without Retraining: Benchmarks and Evaluation of Schema-Derived Constrained Decoding for MLIR

Researchers introduced schema-derived constrained decoding for MLIR, enabling a 1.7B small language model to match or beat 15B-34B LLMs without retraining, while generating code 8x-25x faster.

agentic-systems

Beyond Accuracy and Cost: Latency-Aware LLM Query Routing for Dynamic Workloads

Researchers introduced a novel latency-aware LLM query router that jointly optimizes generation latency, accuracy, and cost. The framework achieves up to a 40% improvement in accuracy-cost utility while maintaining low latency under dynamic workloads.

agentic-systems

MILP-Evo: Closed-Loop Fully Automatic Design of MILP Solvers

MILP-Evo introduces an LLM-guided closed-loop program evolution framework for automatically designing white-box MILP solver components. By iteratively generating and evaluating executable code directly in SCIP, it discovers inspectable and highly competitive domain-specialized solver logic.